Yoko Songs: ‘Who Has Seen the Wind?’
By Madeline Bocaro ©
Yoko’s song, ‘Who Has Seen the Wind?’ is the B-side of John Lennon’s single ‘Instant Karma!’ on Apple Records. The single was recorded in one day and rush-released (“like instant coffee”) and immediately hit No. 5 in the U.K.. Upon its USA release on February 20, 1970 it reached No. 3. It made the Top Ten internationally, rising to No. 2 in Canada.
The lyrics to Yoko’s delicate B-side (recorded at Trident studios) incorporate lines from poet Christina Rossetti’s nursery rhyme, “Who Has Seen the Wind?” (from Sing-Song: A Nursery Rhyme Book, 1872). The lyrics convey the spirituality of nature, being able to see something that is invisible through the effect it has on other things (not unlike karma) through movement or in stillness.
This gentle tune with a simple baroque acoustic arrangement accented with a serene tambourine is sung by Yoko acapella in a high-pitched, quiet and childlike voice. The first verse is in minor, then the song switches to a sweet major key. –
“On that song, the voice is wavering a little, there are shrills and cracks, it’s not professional pop singing, the background is going off a little. There was something of a lost little girl about it. What I was aiming at was the effect you get in Alban Berg’s Wozzeck, where the drunkard sings, a slightly crazed voice, a bit of a broken toy. In that sense it was a quiet desperation.”
– Yoko, Yoko Ono and Her Sixteen-Track Voice, Rolling Stone
to Jonathan Cott – March 18, 1971
Who has seen the wind?
Neither you nor I
But when the trees bow down their heads
The wind is passing by
The Apple Records A-Side (‘Instant Karma!’) label read, ‘PLAY LOUD’. Yoko’s B-side label read, ”PLAY LOW’ or PLAY QUIET’ in the UK (and ‘PLAY SOFT’ in the USA).
John sang a live vocal over the instrumental track of ‘Instant Karma!’ on Top of the Pops during two appearances; on February 12th and also on February 19th 1970. He and Yoko sported crew-cut hairstyles. There are two different appearances. For one, Yoko was blindfolded by a sanitary pad, knitting. In the second version, she holds up signs with the single words ‘Peace’, ‘Love’ ‘Hope’ and ‘Breathe’. They were accompanied by White, Voormann, BP Fallon and Beatles’ assistant Mal Evans on tambourine.
“I was blindfolding myself with a Kotex and knitting something that was going nowhere. I was doing that while a man symbolizing our future was singing ‘WE ALL SHINE ON’.” Yes. We will shine, but for that we have to take the blindfold off and stop knitting what we don’t know what we are knitting. It was my way of showing what we women must free ourselves.”
– Yoko Ono, Twitter Q&A 2016
“My performance was showing to the world what women go through. Chained to the world, blindfolded, and still working hard, knitting.”
– Yoko Ono, Twitter January 15, 2018
“There is a wind that never dies.”
– Yoko, To the Wesleyan People, January 23, 1966
“A long time ago
I said there is a wind that never dies –
I did not know that that wind was you”
– Yoko Ono, Imagine John Lennon book by David L. Wolper (1988)