From Raw Power To Roar Power – Iggy’s Mix vs. Bowie’s mix



By Madeline Bocaro 

© Madeline Bocaro, 2018. No part of this site may be reproduced in whole or in part in any manner without permission of the copyright owner.

A look back on Iggy’s remix for Sony in 1997 in comparison to Bowie’s original mix.

Cheers to Sony Legacy for giving Iggy Pop the ultimatum, “Either you re-mix it or we will!” No matter what Iggy did with the Stooges’ Raw Power master tapes, it would have been inarguably legitimate. He’s the man, and this is it – the way it should have been. But first, let’s be thankful for the way it was.

One day it appeared in all its magnificence, The Holy Grail – the Raw Power album. When it was mixed by David Bowie and released in 1973, the album became history — fast. Admittedly, the original mix was done on old equipment, which further distorted (or enhanced) an already chaotic, unconventional and rebellious sound. The vocals and guitar were so prominent that the low end was barely audible. This razor-sharp edge secured the album’s place in history.

To my teenage ears it sounded like a bunch of angry guys attacking some kind of loud machinery with razor blades. It was a fresh sonic abomination, completely re-defining our idea of music. Raw Power was a dazzling mess, only because of the tight, powerful  relentless band behind the metallic wall of sound – the Stooges. It highly repelled my parents and friends, so I was sure that I had discovered a real treasure. Decades later, it became critically acclaimed, proving there were other people in the world with good taste.

In hindsight, it’s amazing that the line “Love in the middle of a firefight” from ‘Search and Destroy’ is reflected in Bowie’s 1977 song, ‘”Heroes”’ in his lines, “The guns shot above our heads / and we kissed as though nothing could fall.” My favorite lyric is when Iggy rhymes “using technology” with “make no apology” on the same song.

Iggy’s original naïve attempt at mixing in 1974 had all the instruments on one channel and the vocals on the other, just as EMI had done to simulate stereo on the Beatles’ back catalogue. Bowie, whose production Iggy does not discredit under the circumstances, was called upon to rectify the situation.

Iggy’s violent 90’s mix doesn’t rattle and hiss like before. It thumps, roars and pounces like a wildcat. That cheetah’s heart is still full of napalm.  

(Iggy was referencing the Yardbirds’ 1965 hit ‘Heart Full of Soul” in this line). 

It’s been transformed from Raw Power to Roar Power.

You can’t play this mix at low volume. It’s already loud at volume level one, and distortion already sets in at level two. You actually can’t crank it up without destroying your speakers. The cranking is already done for you. How considerate!

This may be the greatest archaeological project of the ages…polishing a huge rough diamond ‘using technology’, defining and clarifying its shine and glory. Iggy claims, “Actually it was a 16-track recording done on 13 tracks. There are 13 clean tracks on Raw Power.”

We’re hearing the bass and drums clearly for the first time. Scott Asheton wasn’t tapping on Tinker Toys after all, and brother Ron Asheton’s bass comes alive, vibrating and pulsating, giving the music its heart. Now the guitar work of James Williamson actually has, dare I say it, warmth. Anarchy is revered, censorship is defied and the music remains wild and alive.

Iggy’s production works especially well on the ballads. On ‘Gimme Danger’ and ‘Penetration’ the acoustic guitar’s hollow sound increases the aural intimacy tenfold. The mix of ‘I Need Somebody’ blows the dust off the bluesy guitar and bass allowing them to shine. Iggy treated his own bitchin’ vocals with utmost respect. The prehistoric transistor AM radio sound has been upgraded to FM Stereo! An added treat is the extra few seconds remaining on some tracks, instead of the original fade-outs. Check out the ending of ‘Death Trip!!’

Iggy’s long-lost ‘burp’ launches ‘Raw Power’ as it well should.

There’s an amazing, long and detailed interview with Iggy in the CD booklet about the old and new mixes. Mick Rock’s original iconic cover art is intact. The serpentine thing on the cover called Iggy was a charismatic monstrosity – androgynous black-lipped, sinuous. Raw. Power. It is a live photo from the Stooges only London performance at the Scala in the summer of 1972, prior to the release of the album. Although the cover was grandiose, the music inside was something entirely deviant. Its aberrant sounds gashed the skin of reason.

On the back cover, Iggy explains, “People kept asking me – musicians, kids I would see, “Have you ever thought about remixing Raw Power?”
“Everything’s still in the red, it’s a very violent mix. The proof’s in the pudding.”

 – Iggy Pop

In 2016, Iggy explained the reason for his remix during a Times Talk interview in New York City.

“Why did I remix it? The master was lost and had surfaced. I wanted the music to get to more people. I wanted them to hear us. The original mix was like a dog whistle they couldn’t hear.”

I’m far from shelving the original mix. It will always be a part of my personal history, having lived with it for decades. Even today it out-sexes the Pistols, out nerves Nirvana and smashes the Pumpkins to bits. Iggy’s new mix is for the musician’s ear, and for kids who were reared on professional sounding recordings. Twenty years on, they’ll be saying, “I hear there’s an original mix that kicks ass!” Let’s hope they’ll be able to track it down.

Ron Asheton’s opinion:

Don Fleming goes, “You know what? When Iggy’s Raw Power mix comes out, I’ll bet you’re gonna go, ‘We always used to say how bad the original David Bowie mix of Raw Power was.’ When you hear Iggy’s mix, I guarantee you’re gonna say, ‘Man, remember that great mix that David Bowie did?'”

“So I heard it, I got the advance copy from his manager, and listened to it. Then I called Fleming and I’m going, “Gee, Don, I just listened to Iggy’s mix of Raw Power. Man, I sure loved that old David Bowie mix. Was it ever great.”…Basically, all that Iggy did was take all the smoothness and all the effects off James [Williamson]’s guitar, so his lead sounds really abrupt and stilty and almost clumsy, and he just put back every single grunt, groan, and word he ever said on the whole fuckin’ soundtrack. He just totally restored everything that was cut out of him in the first mix, and I thought, Damn, I really did like the old Bowie mix better.”

– Ron Asheton to Ken Shimamoto

Calling From the Fun House – November 2, 1998

The Raw Power album has impacted and permeated many decades and generations…so far. ‘Search & Destroy’ was featured in a Nike commercial. Other Stooges songs have come to advertise may other products. What does this mean? Stooges fans have obtained high positions in the advertising industry, and the Stooges music is now considered cool. I would be really impressed if Revlon used ‘Your Pretty Face Is Going To Hell’ to sell their age-defying makeup!

A deluxe version was released on 13 April 2010 titled Raw Power: The Masters Edition, consisting of three CDs, one DVD, a vinyl 7” record, booklet and rare photo prints.

The April 21, 2012 Record Store Day reissue was a limited vinyl re-release. There were two LP’s (one with the remastered 1973 David Bowie mix, the other is a remastered version of the 1997 Iggy Pop mix). Also a 16-page commemorative booklet with quotes from the band, Kings Cross Cinema 1972 live pictures by Mick Rock, and new liner note essays.

Also see my story:

The Streetwalking Cheetah – Iggy Pop’s Jacket

By Madeline Bocaro ©


© Madeline Bocaro 2018. No part of the materials available through may be copied, photocopied, reproduced, translated or reduced to any electronic medium or machine-readable form, in whole or in part, without the  prior written consent of Madeline Bocaro. Any other reproduction in any form without the permission of Madeline Bocaro is prohibited. All materials contained on this site are protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without prior written permission of Madeline Bocaro.





6 thoughts on “From Raw Power To Roar Power – Iggy’s Mix vs. Bowie’s mix

  1. Dear Madeline,
    Another Superb Write Up. What Did You Think Of The Reissued “METALLIC K.O.?” I Prefer The First Issue, Maybe The Greatest Live Album By An American Band. “Do You Want To Hear “LOUIE, LOUIE,” Or Should We Play Our Stuff?” Any NY Dolls/Johnny Thunders In The Archive? Or Jim Carroll/Patti Smith?
    Semper FiDELITY,
    Sean St. X.

    1. Thanks Sean! Re: Your question about the metallic KO reissue… anything that enhances the sound quality of the beer bottles smashing against Iggy’s mic stand is OK by me!

  2. A fantastic wall of sound that no other band can come near Sex Pistols Smashing Pumpkins should never be in same category let alone compqred Fave Stooges track is I’m Sick of You so melodically fervent One piece of advice Iggy stay Shirtless you absolute Animal

Leave a Reply